Legal Insider Articles

Supreme Court Rules Freight Brokers Can Face State Negligence Suits

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court ruled unanimously on May 14, 2026, that freight brokers can be sued under state negligence law for negligently hiring unsafe motor carriers that later cause crashes. The decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC strips the trucking industry’s middlemen of a federal preemption defense that had previously shielded brokers… Read More

Read more: Supreme Court Rules Freight Brokers Can Face State Negligence Suits

Beyond Preemption to Proof: What Montgomery v. Caribe Changes for Broker Liability Litigation

A Clear Safety-Exception Victory In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court held that state-law negligent-selection claims against freight brokers are not barred by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (“FAAAA”) because such claims fall within the Acts safety exception preserving state authority over motor-vehicle safety regulation. In Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, the Court… Read More

Read more: Beyond Preemption to Proof: What Montgomery v. Caribe Changes for Broker Liability Litigation

Medical Malpractice Law Amended by Florida Supreme Court

In a pivotal move with far-reaching implications, the Florida Supreme Court has recently amended the rules governing appellate procedures, allowing defendants to appeal a motion to dismiss a medical malpractice suit based on plaintiff expert qualifications even before a trial concludes. While proponents assert that this alteration will expedite legal proceedings and curtail litigation expenses,… Read More

Read more: Medical Malpractice Law Amended by Florida Supreme Court

PRESS RELEASE: Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Large Insurance Company

On July 13, 2017, the Florida Supreme Court reviewed a decision from the First District Court of Appeals in Government Employees Insurance Co. v. Macedo, 190 So. 3d 1155 (Fla. 1st DCA 2016). In this case, the ambiguity of a policy provision was susceptible to two reasonable interpretations, one provided coverage for attorney’s fees incurred… Read More

Read more: PRESS RELEASE: Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Large Insurance Company
PRESS RELEASE: Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Large Insurance Company

Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Insurer in Equitable Subrogation Case

“The Supreme Court correctly recognized that liability insurers and the people they insure cannot leave a person uncompensated after negligently injuring them, then expect to get paid back,” said Ms. Rodante told Law 360. “Deadbeat debtors don’t get to use ‘equitable’ subrogation.” Swope, Rodante, Newsome & Steinberg Partners, Angela Rodante and Dale Swope, teamed up… Read More

Read more: Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Insurer in Equitable Subrogation Case
Florida Supreme Court Rules Against Insurer in Equitable Subrogation Case

Dale Swope to Speak on Closing Arguments at Al J Cone Trial Advocacy Institute

Dale Swope, the firm’s founding partner, will be a speaker at the upcoming Al J Cone Trial Advocacy Institute presented by the Florida Justice Association on August 6th-8th. at the Gaylord Palms Resort & Convention Center in Kissimmee, Florida. Currently Treasurer of the FJA, Mr. Swope’s lecture will focus on the topic of Closing Arguments.… Read More

Read more: Dale Swope to Speak on Closing Arguments at Al J Cone Trial Advocacy Institute
Dale Swope to Speak on Closing Arguments at Al  J Cone Trial Advocacy Institute

Supreme Court of Florida Approves Waiver of Future Negligence

Occasional carnival-goers, infrequent go-cart drivers, and once-in-a-while horse-back riders beware. . . That should be the warning on the newest opinion on exculpatory agreements in Florida. I’m sure everyone at one point or another has participated in some “dangerous” activity like hang-gliding or canoeing or horse-back riding and been given one of those “release” things… Read More

Read more: Supreme Court of Florida Approves Waiver of Future Negligence

Say What You Mean To Say (When Serving Proposals for Settlement)

PFS’s must strictly comply with Florida Statute 768.79 and Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.442. In addition, the offeree must be able to independently evaluate his/her respective claim, irrespective of other parties’ decisions. An offer conditioned on an event entirely out of the offeree’s control, like the tender of a settlement check by the offeree’s… Read More

Read more: Say What You Mean To Say (When Serving Proposals for Settlement)

“Facebook Privilege”

The Privacy Interest That Doesn’t Exist, but Most People Think They Have In the last decade or so, Facebook and other social media has taken over as the main way many people in the U.S. communicate. Forty years ago, people would share their vacation photos with friends using slide projectors. They would wish their friends… Read More

Read more: “Facebook Privilege”
Avvo 5-Star Client Rating
Tampa Bay Trial Lawyers Association
Firm Partners have AV Preeminent Rating from Martindale-Hubbell
Board Certification from The Florida Bar
Members of the American College of Coverage Counsel
Featured in Tampa Magazine's Top Lawyers in 2023
Best Law Firms 2026 Award
BCG Top Law Firm Award 2025
Florida Legal Elite 2024
Florida Legal Elite Hall of Fame
National Trial Lawyers Top 100 award
National Trial Lawyers Top 10 Insurance Bad Faith
Awarded "The Best Lawyers in America"
National Association of Distinguished Counsel Nations Top One Percent 2025
Members of the American Board of Trial Advocates
Our attorneys are members of the Florida Justice Association